Our take We’re big fans of hot chocolate, but the little freeze-dried marshmallows that come with powdered mixes are pretty sad. Up your hot drink game with these handmade marshmallows. Wondermade ditched the corn syrup you find in most brands in favor of real cane sugar as the main base ingredient, alongside kosher gelatin, pure vanilla extract, confectioner’s sugar, and cream of tartar. Each box contains 16 square-inch cubes. Open with care, or you might end up eating the whole thing in one go. The marshmallows come in a dizzying variety of flavors; we recommend starting with the Bourbon.