Access Special Backpacker.com Features, Register Now!

Is Gore-Tex the Best?

Is Gore-Tex still the #1 all-time best waterproof material you can buy?

Question:

Is Gore-Tex still the #1 all-time best waterproof material you can buy? Or are other brands’ waterproofing just the same with a different name? Just wondering if it’s worth paying the extra money for the Gore-Tex brand? Thanks!

Submitted by - Robin - Oshkosh, WI

Answer:

This is a big question with a long-winded answer. We just finished a pretty exhaustive test of the latest and greatest shell technologies (check it out in our online September 2011 issue) and yes, the new Gore-Tex Active Shell was awesome. So were the other four candidates: Polartec Neoshell, Mountain Hardwear Dry.Q Elite, and Columbia Omni-Dry. These 4 fabrics are also mighty spendy ($350-$480, and Gore-Tex is NOT the most expensive), so, let’s face it: they’re not for everyone.

Here’s my honest opinion: There are tons of jackets out there—some really well priced “house fabrics”—that will keep you dry, if that is your primary goal. But if you need a jacket that’s really breathable as well, that’s when it pays to fork out some extra money.

Waterproof/breathable shells fall into two general categories, each with pros and cons:

Membranes: These are very thin microporous films with holes too small to let water in, but large enough to let sweat vapor out. Membranes are laminated between a face fabric (often nylon) and a liner (to protect the membrane from wear and dirt). Pros: Membranes are more breathable and more durable. Con: They’re also considerably more expensive.

Coatings: This is when the inside face of a fabric is treated with a microporous coating that also blocks water from entering but let’s out a degree of sweat vapor. Pros: Coated shells are very light, packable, and affordable (often under $100). Cons: They are not as durable (coatings eventually wear off) or breathable as membranes.

Bottom line, Robin: Gore-Tex is great, but there are lots of other great membranes, too. Determine your budget and your needs, then decide which category of raingear you need. Check out all these shell reviews we’ve done in recent years.

1 Comment

  1. chanelview

    cheap jordans eve that over time that will change”It’s light, easy to handle, and I’ll use it to read booksSchmitt, the district’s director of human resources, also didn’t help Vijayendran’s case much, though the jury may wind up sympathizing with the former principal”Spelman is unusually well-suited for such a move as it will likely face little uproar from alumniBeijing is tightening security as its all-important Communist Party congress approaches, and some of the measures seem downright bizarreOther employees and/or customers were in the store during the robberies, but no one was hurt in either incidentThe economics of college athletics vary widely from big-time programs to Division III schools where intercollegiate athletics are little more than another extracurricular activitys rules seem extraordinary, perhaps in an effort to smooth a once-a-decade transition that has already been bumpyThis has all been really bad timing for Joshua Suzanne, who owns a vintage store called Rags-A-GoGo in the West VillageA smaller tablet is the first device to be added to Apple’s compact portfolio under Cook, who took over from Jobs just before his death a year ago It’s just more practical to have the mini because I found it a bit too big As GetJar Founder and Executive Chairman Ilja Laurs explains, the SDK works like a billing platform
    coach outlet store Founder and Executive Chairman Ilja Laurs explains, the SDK works like a billing platform7-inch display as the previous version but with a faster A6X processor and better Wi-Fis sad that it has to come to Xbox Live bans just to get people to act civil toward one another, but thatCheckout”We have been investigating since the first robbery and are devoting many resources so we can quickly resolve the issue and locate the suspect,” Lockhart saidFor Tatum, there is also an element of social responsibilityThe airline’s four-minute safety video featuring the character Gollum and film director Peter Jackson got more than 2 million hits on YouTube within a day of its posting”Pontoon” was something of a departure for Little Big Town, whose members include Karen Fairchild, Kimberly Schlapman, Jimi Westbrook and Phillip Sweet”Reviewers have applauded Apple for squeezing most of the iPad’s features into a smaller package that can be comfortably manipulated with one handbusiness apps Yet, while you may know it as an app store (after all, thatm
    retro jordans l never forget the tragedym And about how this town pulled together He told her that he called the girl into the classroom to prepare a lesson on Helen Keller, which he had been using for years GetJar The image is really good and it’s got the fast A5 chip too,” Vohradsky saidA smaller tablet is the first device to be added to Apple’s compact portfolio under Cook, who took over from Jobs just before his death a year ago The 35-year-old teacher, in jail pending his trial, faces a maximum sentence of 75 years to life if he is convicted It gets to the point where you have no idea how many rubber bands you used, and you can’t see the first one “Students who really want to be at Spelman will still come to Spelman Whaley Elementary struggled to convey why she accepted teacher Craig Chandler’s explanation for his disturbing behavior — that it was part of a lesson plan about Helen Keller””Because Willie,” Underwood said, “it appears there’s been some doping charges
    http://www.jordanshoesll.com an old saying, most commonly associated with Watergate, that the cover-up is worse than the crimeThe airline’s four-minute safety video featuring the character Gollum and film director Peter Jackson got more than 2 million hits on YouTube within a day of its postingeThe government has blocked searches for the phrase “18th Party Congress” on websites including China like upgrades, new levels, virtual, goods and so on Prosecutors must prove the perjurer knowingly lied about something important”They also poked a little fun at the night’s honored guest, Willie Nelson, who was due to receive a lifetime achievement award and perform with Tim McGraw, Faith Hill, Lady Antebellum and Blake Shelton One of the most beloved figures in not just country music, but American popular culture, Nelson was stopped several times for hugsA Deloitte spokesman said 420 staff will lose their jobs as a result of the administration and 32 stores will close” She said in e-mails, Curley was “seemingly using words to try to mask the true topic of the e-mail”Investigators are still searching for clues in a daring smash and grab robbery of jewelry at a store earlier this week”It’s a great honor and I’m glad I achieved something,” he said
    coach outlet n the taxi windows”It’s light, easy to handle, and I’ll use it to read books “For Tatum, there is also an element of social responsibility9-inch slateThe founder tells us that developers who have integrated its currency into their apps have doubled their revenue and, in territories where Google Checkout isns rules seem extraordinary, perhaps in an effort to smooth a once-a-decade transition that has already been bumpy They look intolerant without looking impatient model, which allows third-party app makers to distribute apps for most of the major mobile platforms By the time all the repairs are done, Nicaj thinks he’ll be out a few hundred thousand dollars
    http://www.coachoutletstorell.com was launched in 2010 by Steve Jobs and since then it has taken a big chunk out of PC sales, upending the industry and reinventing mobile computing with its apps-based ecosystemre found to be making sexist comments, donR Wear a little wider shoe,” he says with a shrug She says she needed the money from this week to keep her in business during January and February, when things get slowSo much of what the attorney general said Thursday is old news — extremely relevant, but well-knownre similar (duh), but that 500 of my friends or colleagues or people who are exactly like me happen to be using and loving the appChina always tightens security for high-profile events, like much of the rest of the world4 million annually A similar robbery occurred at the store shortly after 8 p

Leave a Reply

W3 Total Cache is currently running in Pro version Development mode.